Member's Mark Key Lime Pie, 41 oz.

Our Member’s Mark smooth, cool and creamy Key lime pie begins in the warm sun and sea breeze of the tropics. Sure, there may have been Key lime pies before this one—but trust us, this is the one you won't forget. Get the taste of summer in every bite and share it with those you love, too.

What Makes This Pie So Special?

Ripe and juicy key limes are flown in, carefully selected and processed by extracting and straining the juice to ensure a top-quality Key lime flavor. Key limes give this filling a distinct lime flavor that's tart, but not too acidic. We then finish the pie with a premium whipped topping, which balances out the tartness of the Key lime filling. This gives our pie a clean and natural citrus flavor that sets it apart from others.

A Crust Unlike Any Other

Think we stopped at just the Key limes? We pair the delicious filling with a distinctive graham cracker crust using only the finest ingredients. Our fully-formed cookie crusts are made with a custom blend of fresh cookies, all-natural honey and homemade molasses, giving it a uniquely rich flavor and the perfect crumbly texture.

Best Drinks to Pair with Key Lime Pie

We recommend pairing this traditional pie with a glass of Prosecco or Moscato. The prominent fruity flavor of the Prosecco and floral aromas of the Moscato, along with their citrus notes, complement the sweet, tart and citrusy flavors of the pie. It's a match made in dessert heaven.